2024-08-02 00:00:00 Rumah-rumah hancur, penjarahan, dan keinginan balas dendam. Seorang mantan tentara cadangan Pasukan Pertahanan Israel (IDF) menuduh adanya pelanggaran serius yang dilakukan pasukan Israel di Gaza, dan kurangnya disiplin dalam struktur komando, dalam sebuah wawancara dengan Berita.
Berita — Destroyed homes, looting, and a desire for revenge.
A former Israel Defense Forces (IDF) reservist has alleged serious misconduct by Israeli forces in Gaza, and a lack of discipline in the command structure, in an interview with Berita.
Yuval Green, a 26-year-old former paratrooper, is one of a handful of soldiers who have served in Israelâs war against Hamas and are now publicly criticizing the way it is being prosecuted.
Green described the behavior and alleged misdeeds of his reservist peers while serving in the Palestinian enclave, and the day he decided to tell his commanders he could no longer be part of his unit.
Israel launched its military offensive in Gaza on October 7 after Hamas attacked southern Israel.
At least 1,200 people were killed, and more than 250 others abducted in the assault, according to Israeli authorities.
Israeli military action in the strip has killed nearly 40,000 Palestinians and injured over 90,000, according to Gazaâs Ministry of Health.
As of early July, nearly 2 million people had been displaced in Gaza â almost the entire population, according to figures from the United Nations.
Green, who served as a medic in his unit, told Berita that prior to October 7 â when he was recruited for reserve duty â he had intended to leave the army, objecting to its conduct in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
He had planned to tell his comrades on October 8, but after Hamas attacked, he felt duty-bound to support them as they were mobilized for the war.
âWhen the 7th of October struck, it was difficult for me at this time to tell them that Iâm not willing to come with them,â Green said.
âSo I decided to join my friends ⦠I didnât know what would be the right thing to do.â Yuval Green, a former Israeli paratrooper, speaks to Berita.
Berita Atmosphere of âdemonizing Gazansâ Green told Berita that he served in the Gaza perimeter in November last year before being sent into the strip on December 2, spending 51 days in the city of Khan Younis, in the south.
He said that the anger felt by Israelis after October 7 and calls for revenge were expressed openly in his unit, as they waited to be sent into Gaza, and called it the âdemonizingâ of Palestinians.
âIn the days before we entered Khan Younis ⦠there was this atmosphere that was kind of growing of demonizing the Gazans,â he said, adding that he heard people âspeaking about killing, ruining all of Gaza.
Wiping it out became something that people (were discussing), as if it was some kind of a legitimate idea.â IDF rules of engagement in Gaza have been under great scrutiny.
Green claims that IDF commanders on the ground seemed to acquiesce to soldiersâ desires to have fewer restrictions on their conduct than in previous incursions.
âI felt like my commanders were trying to kind of go with the soldiers and try to say things that they thought â¦Â (were) what the soldiers wanted to hear.
You know, saying things like, âWeâre not going to have any boundaries in Gaza this time.ââ Green said he did not serve during earlier cycles of violence in Gaza but took part in guard duty on the Gaza perimeter and in the West Bank, as well as training.
A view of destruction in Khan Younis, in southern Gaza, on December 17, 2023, after weeks of Israeli bombardment.
Mahmud Hams/AFP/Getty Images/File âWe donât care enoughâ about Palestinian lives The war in Gaza has caused widespread material destruction to homes, infrastructure, hospitals and schools.
Green says he witnessed the âunnecessaryâ destruction of Palestinian homes.
âWeâve seen a lot of destruction that was not necessarily related to military reasons.
Everything tends to (get) really mix up, you know â people are destroying houses because they believe that they should (get) revenge (for) what happened on (October 7) and it mixes up with the reasons to destroy houses for military reasons,â Green said, adding he witnessed âchaos â¦Â I could tell you 100% that weâve destroyed houses at least for reasons that ⦠we donât care enough about the lives of Palestinians.â Describing the extent of the damage in Gaza, he said, âYou canât imagine it.
Cities that are completely ruined.â Palestinians carry out search and rescue operations following an airstrike on December 7, 2023, in Khan Younis.
Ahmad Hasaballah/Getty Images/File Accusations of looting Green told Berita that one of the things that bothered him most was witnessing what he alleged was the looting of Palestinian homes by soldiers in his own unit.
âYouâre seeing looting by your peers all the time. That was something (that) was very difficult for me to see.
I mean, people were taking âsouvenirsâ (from) the Palestiniansâ houses, which I think directly relates to the demonization weâve seen before the entrance to Khan Younis,â he said.
âPeople were taking, you know, necklaces and doing graffiti on the walls and â¦Â leaving behind damage to the houses that was just completely unnecessary.â When asked if he thinks this behavior was condoned by IDF commanders, Green said that officially, they disapproved of such conduct â but were unable to stop it.
Palestinians cycle past destroyed buildings leveled in a previous Israeli military bombardment of Beit Lahia, in the northern Gaza Strip on Monday.
Omar Al-Qattaa/AFP/Getty Images Related article Killing of Hamas leader leaves Gaza ceasefire hopes dangling by a thread âThe superior commanders of the IDF, I think they do believe that this shouldnât happen â looting or graffiti,â Green said.
âBut I donât think (the IDF) has the resources to stop it, and I think, you know, it all comes down to the soldiers (in) the field.
You canât stop any soldier from doing things.â While witnessing the alleged looting, Green said he confronted his peers, which resulted in âa lot of arguments,â but he was unable to sway his superiors to act: âSome of them agreed with me, some of them didnât â or some of them, you know, were in between.â âBut all of them werenât able to control our actions.â The decision to leave In the end, one specific moment pushed Green to make the tough decision to leave his unit: when a commander allegedly ordered the burning of a Palestinian home they were stationed in.
âAt some point, my commander told my platoon to burn down the house weâre staying at,â Green recounted. âAnd I went to him, I approached him and I asked him, âWhy are we doing that?â And he gave me a few reasons, and I think those reasons were just not strong enough.â âThey were, you know, military type of reasons, but they (were mixed up with) the revenge type of reasons.
Now, I think this is just whatâs going on in Gaza.
Israel is doing things because it needs to fulfil a type of military purpose, but it all mixes up with our need for â or the Israeli need for â revenge.â Illustration by Alberto Mier/Berita Related article The US held off sanctioning this Israeli army unit despite evidence of abuses.
Now its forces are shaping the fight in Gaza âI said, âIâm not willing to participate in that.
Iâm not destroying a house that belonged to a few families that would become homeless because of that â and Iâm leaving.â And I just (left) with the next car that went out.â Green said he decided to speak out publicly to put pressure on the Israeli government to accept a ceasefire and hostage deal.
The Israeli government said this week that it was Hamas leadership that was preventing an agreement.
âI think there are concrete deals on the table right now, that Hamas is agreeing to, that make sense.
I mean, those deals say that all the hostages would be freed â and Israel is not accepting the ending of the war.
And this is crazy,â Green said.
Green added that Israelâs alleged refusal to accept a deal was causing the deaths of hostages.
âIâve seen it from within,â he said.
âI mean, we said nothing before we entered Gaza about the hostages.
We could have killed them, you know, any moment, and itâs something that has happened.
We know about more than 10 hostages that were killed directly from Israeli bombings or, you know, the three hostages that were killed,â referring to an incident of friendly fire by the IDF in December, in which soldiers fatally shot three hostages.
The possibility that hostages have been killed during Israeli bombardments is a sensitive one in Israel.
There have been occasions when officials have announced that hostages were believed to have been killed while in captivity, but at no point have any such announcements been attributed to Israeli airstrikes.
The Israeli army has not responded to Beritaâs request for comment on Greenâs claims.
âWe have to tell our government to stop the war.
This is the only right solution to save the lives of Palestinians that are dying every day and going through a living hell the past few months, saving the lives of soldiers, Israeli soldiers, that are now present in Gaza and dying every day, and obviously the lives of hostages.â Israeli military vehicles in southern Israel, near the border with Gaza, on December 25, 2023.
Menahem Kahana/AFP/Getty Images/File Facing criticism at home In June, Green cosigned a letter with 40 other reservists refusing to serve in the southern Gaza city of Rafah.
He is one of only three soldiers who have come out publicly, and his family and friends have voiced concern over his decisions.
âObviously itâs something very controversial in Israel, but I was willing to sacrifice, you know, my privacy and (to come) out with a topic as controversial as that, because I believe that right now, itâs a matter of life and death.
âWhen people are criticizing me for that, and Iâve heard people ⦠that said they were worried that I might get hurt in that process â that always felt very weird because, you know, I went inside Gaza.
I literally have risked my life.
But people are now more afraid that I might get hurt, you know, by just coming out with words,â he added. âItâs part of the problem with our situation right now.â Reflecting on the violence committed by Hamas, he also urged Palestinians not to support Hamas or call for an intifada: âThey donât understand that those calling for violence are damaging the Palestinian cause, and have been killing Palestinians for years now ⦠I support Palestine too, but donât confuse between supporting Palestine and supporting the violence of Hamas.â Berita has reached out to the IDF for comment on Greenâs allegations.
Responding to Greenâs allegations, the IDF stated: âThe actions of the IDF and its operational activity in particular are subject to Israeli law and international law, which is reflected, among other things, in the rules of engagement among other military orders ⦠IDF commanders are guided by values of the IDF ââand lead the soldiers on the battlefield in a professional manner.
When events that defer from the expected conduct occur, they are handled by the commanders as required.
âIn some cases, IDF forces are required to act to remove a threat posed to them from buildings located in the territory of the Gaza Strip.
The destruction of buildings is done with the appropriate means.
Actions done otherwise, and not as a result of operational needs, are contrary to the armyâs orders and the IDFâs values ââand are examined.
Taking property that is not in accordance with the armyâs orders is prohibited by law and is not in line with the values ââof the IDF.
Incidents in which forces acted not in accordance with the orders and the law are examined and will continue to be examined, including as part of investigations by the MPCID (Military Police Criminal Investigation Division).
As a general rule, when details concerning concrete events are given, they are reviewed and dealt with accordingly.â